Booklist Reviews
Dasher, a reindeer, doesn't want to live her life as part of J. P. Finnegan's Traveling Circus and Menagerie. She's only happy when children come to view the circus reindeer and feed them carrots. Dasher dreams of the land her mother once lovingly described: "It was a magical place," she would say. "The air was crisp and cold, and the ground was always covered with a cool blanket of white snow." When the opportunity for freedom presents itself, Dasher reluctantly leaves her family behind and runs away. Traveling north to her parents' homeland, she encounters a bearded man with a sleigh filled with gifts. His horse is having trouble pulling the heavy vehicle, so Dasher offers to help. Richly colored illustrations in watercolor, gouache, pencil, and pastel delineate the history of how Dasher volunteered to pull Santa's sleigh and help him bring joy to children on Christmas. Readers will enjoy this lush new holiday tale that focuses on Santa's original reindeer. Preschool-Grade 2. Copyright 2019 Booklist Reviews.
BookPage Reviews
Seasonal books to make spirits bright
Whether you're waiting for Santa or the winter solstice, these six picture books capture the excitement, wonder and joy of the holiday season.
Collectors of Christmas tales mustn't miss Dasher, Matt Tavares' exhilarating chronicle of how Santa went from a single horse to a team of flying reindeer pulling his sleigh. Determined Dasher is the star of this show, escaping from a difficult life in a traveling circus and doggedly finding her way to the North Pole. Tavares excels at Christmas stories (Red & Lulu, The Gingerbread Pirates), and young readers are apt to inhale every word of this yarn. As an illustrator, Tavares is a master of dramatic light, emotion and mood, as well as deep, vibrant color, whether he's depicting Dasher's family penned in at the circus or Santa's sleigh magically lifting up into the air. Dasher is sure to join the stacks of enduring Christmas favorites read by families year after year.
Kids are always trying to outsmart Santa, but young Freddy Melcher hopes to finally succeed in The Great Santa Stakeout. After all, he's obsessed with St. Nick, dressing in a Santa suit for every holiday—even Talk Like a Pirate Day! This #1 Santa fan is sure he's got a failsafe plan for capturing a selfie with his idol, and his plan seems thorough, complete with meticulous preparation and blueprints. Betsy Bird's snappy text enlivens this rollicking, action-packed tale, while Caldecott Medalist Dan Santat's illustrations dramatically capture Freddy's wide-eyed excitement. This modern Santa caper will keep the magic alive for young readers counting the days until the big guy shimmies down their chimneys.
On a more serious note, Between Us and Abuela: A Family Story From the Border is a poignant story set at the wall separating Tijuana and San Diego. Young María and her little brother are traveling with their mother by bus. Their destination is an annual day when Border Patrol officials allow groups of people to gather in an area called the enforcement zone to talk and touch fingertips with those on the other side of the border. María and her family are going to see their Abuela, whom they haven't seen for five years. "For a moment," María notes, "the fences are invisible"—until she realizes her brother can't give Abuela the drawing he made for her. Mitali Perkins' story is a perfect introduction for children to how borders separate families, delicately embracing the reunion's joy and enduring sadness. Sara Palacios' illustrations cheerfully capture the love among separated families as well as the realities of the border wall. This superb picture book is a holiday story that deserves to be a year-round read.
While some things are designed to keep people apart, others draw them together. One snowy morning, Bear wakes to a new star on the horizon and knows it's time to begin his annual search for a special tree in The Bear and the Star. Bear soon finds a majestic evergreen on top of a windswept hill, and as "his call echoed through canyon and valley, between boulder and butte, across prairie and lake," he summons living creatures far and wide. Lola M. Schaefer's spare but mesmerizing text invites inclusiveness, as "People put down hammer and hoe, grass and thatch, knife and rice, shield and sword." Bethanne Andersen's snowy scenes, reminiscent of Eric Carle's Dream Snow, beautifully depict the rich reds of the desert, the warmth of tropical fields, a menagerie of species and a glorious array of people. The Bear and the Star is a stunning and universal tribute to peace, joy, love and winter celebrations.
Years ago, Susan Cooper wrote a beloved poem that has remained a mainstay of John Langstaff's phenomenal theatrical production Christmas Revels, performed each year across the country (see it if you can!). Now transformed into a picture book, The Shortest Day is a joyful and timeless celebration of the winter solstice that will surely become a classic. Even very young children will enjoy Cooper's splendid, stately words: "And everywhere down the centuries of the snow-white world / Came people singing, dancing, / To drive the dark away." The multitalented, Caldecott Honor-winning Carson Ellis (Du Iz Tak?) is the perfect illustrator for this project, using muted colors to accentuate the changing interplay between the sun and surrounding darkness. Beginning with a scene of prehistoric people and a godlike sun figure walking the earth, Ellis echoes the sweep of ages so prevalent in Cooper's poem, showing a progression of people and homes, ending with a modern house and children. In a helpful author's note, Cooper explains both solstice celebrations and the evolution of her poem. In her words, "Welcome Yule!"
When Little Redbird injures her wing and can't fly south for the winter, she seeks shelter in several hardwood trees, who all turn her down. Happily, the evergreen trees welcome her with open boughs in Why Evergreens Keep Their Leaves. Annemarie Riley Guertin's text is a lively retelling of this holiday legend, while Helena Pérez Garcia's illustrations burst off the page with beautifully vibrant colors and intriguing textures, design and depth. In a not-so-easy feat, Garcia instills all of these trees with plenty of personality without resorting to anthropomorphism. This story, which never grows old, is not only a visual delight but a well-told and timely tale of kindness.
Copyright 2019 BookPage Reviews.Horn Book Guide Reviews
Long ago, a reindeer family in a traveling circus lived, unhappily, far from the North Star and that magical place where ‘the air was crisp and cold, and the ground was always covered with...snow.' These soothing phrases echo throughout as youngest reindeer Dasher escapes; helps Santa and his horse; and finds a new home for her family at the North Pole. Painterly mixed-media illustrations reflect the pleasantly nostalgic tone used throughout this Santa's-reindeer origin story. Copyright 2021 Horn Book Guide Reviews.
Horn Book Magazine Reviews
Long ago, a reindeer family in a traveling circus and menagerie lived, unhappily, far from the North Star and that magical place where "the air was crisp and cold, and the ground was always covered with a cool blanket of white snow." Echoes of these soothing phrases repeat throughout as youngest reindeer Dasher escapes; helps Santa and his horse, Silverbell; and finds a new home for her family at the North Pole. While Tavares leaves some details to readers' imaginations (what magic makes the reindeer all-of-a-sudden fly?), Dasher's personality is clearly conveyed through her fervent wish for a better life, and her love of her family...and of carrots. Tavares's painterly watercolor, gouache, pencil, and pastel illustrations reflect the pleasantly nostalgic tone used throughout this Santa's-reindeer origin story. Cynthia K. Ritter November/December 2019 p.35 Copyright 2019 Horn Book Magazine Reviews.
Kirkus Reviews
An origin story for Santa's "eight tiny reindeer." Nearly two centuries after "A Visit From St. Nicholas" originated Santa Claus' "coursers" and "called them by name," Tavares offers readers their backstory, centered on "a brave young doe named Dasher." First, the frontmatter notes "a time...when Santa's sleigh was pulled...by a single horse, named Silverbell." Ensuing pages depict not a wintry scene of Santa and Silverbell but a parched landscape with a crowd of people peering at penned reindeer as part of the cruel J.P. Finnegan's Traveling Circus and Menagerie. Illustrated details in clothing and material culture suggest a 19th-century American setting, but the focus is on the animals' cramped misery. Though kind children provide solace through carrots and smiles, Dasher's main comfort comes from her mother's stories of a northern homeland with "crisp, cold air and cool blankets of white snow." One windy night, the pen's gate blows open and Dasher escapes. While following the North Star, she encounters Santa (depicted as a white-bearded white man) and a weary Silverbell and offers to help pull the sleigh. Tavares' art is at its best in such magical scenes, which fairly beg to be made into Christmas cards, but the storytelling falters due to the ease with which the other reindeer escape when Santa grants Dasher her "best wish yet" and rescues her family. Gorgeous illustrations make this one sure to fly off shelves "like the down of a thistle." (Picture book. 3-8) Copyright Kirkus 2019 Kirkus/BPI Communications. All rights reserved.
Publishers Weekly Reviews
In this prequel to the Rudolph story, Tavares explains how Santa ended up with his original reindeer crew. Young Dasher and her reindeer family languish in a circus, displayed as zoo animals under the hot sun by day and pulling the menagerie's wagons at night. "The air was crisp and cold," says Mama, recalling her birthplace under the North Star, "and the ground was always covered with a cool blanket of white snow." Seizing an opportunity to escape, Dasher follows the North Star, and finds Santa and Silverbell—an affable, plodding horse who struggles to pull the heavy load: "I'm sorry, Santa. The sleigh is just so heavy this year." Happily for all, a bit of magic assists gift delivery, and Santa's gratitude leads to granted wishes and a reindeer reunion. Tavares's classically painted figures are lit by moonlight and falling snow in this cozy antidote to holiday hullabaloo. Ages 4–8. (Sept.)
Copyright 2019 Publishers Weekly.SLJ Express Reviews